Shock Collars: The good, the bad and the ugly

Shock Collars

About the Author: Nettie Finley, the Professional Dog Trainer at MyPetDoggie. Specializing in behavior rehabilitation, Nettie leads our team with her effective training techniques. As a certified canine behaviorist, she brings transformative change to challenging behavior cases. Her experience and expertise elevate our content, providing practical, insightful training advice for our readers. Also, she loves her Cavapoo!

Shock training can be a very hot topic within the dog community. They are used to train dogs to stay in or out of a certain area and to stop them from certain unwanted behaviors.

When it comes to your dog, the way you train them is your choice to make the shock collars: the good, the bad, and the ugly. The jolt the dog receives from a collar is not painful at all. It merely grabs their attention so that a behavioral correction can be made. 

To balance the training, a shock collar is a must-have training tool that will achieve results quickly.

But still, there are some people who take a strong stand against the use of shock collars on dogs. 

In their opinion, this method makes them more aggressive. But the cold fact is that some methods are effective while others are ineffective and every method comes with its pros and cons.

Lastly, It all depends on how you use the shock collar male home good, bad, and ugly.

  1. There are some positive and negative things associated with the shocking collars merely depends on how you use them.
  2. The Good: A shock collar is one of the precise training tools that 1⁄3 of dog owners use to make their dog behave well, helping in learn new commands, and making him more disciplined.
  3. The Bad: Because there are risk of misuse, shock collars becomes a tool of punishment rather than positive reinforcement resulting increase in aggressive behavior in dogs.
  4. The Ugle: Shock collar when used incorrectly, can cause dogs physical pain, injury, and psychological stress, including severe anxiety and displaced aggression.
  5. Bottom: Just like everything, shock collars also come with pros & cons. So, if you’re using a shock collar on your dog then notice how they react, if the dog feels comfortable you can continue to use it for positive training, and if not then stop using it.
Key Takeaways

Shock Collars: The good, the bad and the ugly

There are some positive and negative things associated with the shocking collars. Some consider it a good thing for training and some are against the use of these collars on dogs. Everyone has their own opinions based on their experiences. Moreover, the most important thing is that you can make the shock collars good, bad, and ugly.

Because it merely depends on how you use the shock collar. If you use it in the right way you get good results and if you use it carelessly. All you end up hurting is your dog. Moving further let’s dive into the good, bad, and ugly aspects of shocking collars.

The Good

Shock Collars
A dog running after wearing a good shock collar

In shock collars, the good thing is that the dog behaves when you hit the beep which the dog has never heard before. Within seconds you follow it up with a jolt. The dog very quickly learns that the beep means a jolt will follow if he does not look to you for instruction. Again, this works if all goes according to plan.

Effective Training Tool

The shock collar is one of the most effective training tools for adult dogs. They help you to make good changes in the dog like declining his bad behavior, helping in learn new commands, making him more disciplined, and so on. This is the positive reinforcement of the shock collars. If you follow all the guidelines and use the collar effectively it surely gets you good results in return.

Precision in Training

You can get precise in training a dog with a shock collar when you follow all the steps that are important. Most importantly you can use the shock collar with all the guidance you get from the veteran or a dog trainer. You can imply all this while training a dog. First of all, you can buy a quality product, then start with the basic commands and let your dog get used to it.

Next, show him the behavior that you want him to adopt. Use the vibration mode on the collar and at last quit the training and repeat it every time and slowly increase the shock. 

Off-Leash Control

When introducing your dog to off-leash training using a collar, it is important to first associate the vibration of the collar with a command they already know. Most dogs begin to understand the relationship between pulling and the vibration or stimulation after several activations of the collar. The pulling behavior diminishes quickly in some dogs and more gradually in others.

Quick Behavior Modification

The shock collar is a quick behavior modification device that can change the dog’s behavior quickly. To do that, you need to associate the shock collar with rewards, similar to using a clicker. So, when they feel that buzz, they immediately pay attention to you and obey because they know a treat is on its way.

The Bad

The bad side of using devices like shock collars in training is that the dog doesn’t necessarily learn to do a behavior. They learn how to avoid pain. Learning through avoidance will become quickly extinguished and must be continually reinforced.

The Bad  (1)
A dog is tired of wearing a lot of harnesses on his body

So these collars usually need to be used for the duration of the dog’s life.

Risk of Misuse

The misuse of shock collars has adverse effects on the dog and causes damage to his skin. Excessive shock makes the dog nervous and fearful. In fact, overdoing it with one shock after another has the potential to anger your dog. 

Lack of Positive Association

Shock collars rely on punishment rather than positive reinforcement, which can hinder the development of good behavior. The use of punishment can cause anxious or fearful responses and may even increase aggressive behavior in some dogs. 

Potential for Harm

Shock collars can cause dogs physical pain, injury, and psychological stress, including severe anxiety and displaced aggression. Individual animals vary in their temperaments and pain thresholds; a shock that seems mild to one dog might be severe to another.

Short-Term Compliance

The shock collars have short-term compliance and training with shock collars causes long-lasting stress effects. These collars only work for a short time and if you use them for a long period it can reverse the effects. From changing bad behavior to good behavior the dog can turn more aggressive if the shock collars are used for a longer time period. 

The Ugly

The ugliness of the shock collar is the punishment that is being associated with the shock collar. Punished behavior is not forgotten, it’s only suppressed and the unwanted behavior returns when punishment is no longer present. It causes an increase in aggression.

The Ugly
A dog is happy after wearing a collar

Moreover, it creates fear that can generalize into undesirable behaviors. 

Ethical Concerns

The general perception is that it is harmful and unethical, especially when used frequently. It can cause dogs physical pain, injury, and psychological stress, including severe anxiety and displaced aggression and in some cases it can lead to death. Furthermore, the experts advise against using shock collars.

Lack of Positive Reinforcement

The shock collars lack positive reinforcement if not used properly. If it is misused it has the potential for physical injury. The shock collars can cause burns, wounds, and other injuries to the dog’s neck. This is especially true if the collar is not fitted correctly or the stimulus intensity is too high.

Alternative Methods Available

There are several alternative methods available that you can use instead of a shock collar. It might seem that using rewards as a way to discipline a dog is counterproductive, but it’s actually a powerful training method. By learning that certain types of behavior result in affection and prizes, they will quickly realize they need to continue that practice.

Controversial Legal Status

Shock collars are legal in every state in the US despite being banned in many other countries. These collars are legal because there are currently no federal laws or regulations that prohibit their use in dog training. The decision to ban or restrict e-collars is left up to individual states and municipalities.

Types of Shock Collar
A dog wears a shock collar on his neck while goes for playing


Now it’s time to end this conversation about whether the shock collars are good, bad, or ugly.

Moving towards the ending note of this article I conclude that to make a shock collar good or bad it merely depends upon the user. How you use the shock collar makes him good, bad, and ugly.

Every shock collar has its own pros and cons and it’s up to you to choose the best and authentic one for your dog for training.

If your dog feels comfortable in a collar he will be easy in training and if he feels uncomfortable in a collar he may hurt himself and avoid training as well.

Lastly, shock collars are an effective tool to train your dog and if you use them in a proper way you get good results at the end.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like